Baitfish of the Fall Run | Fall Run Survival Guide

The fall run finds a smorgasbord of bait cruising the surf for stripers to enjoy on their long journey south.

The fall run is a chaotic and wonderful time to be a striped bass angler. Even though fishermen throughout most of the Northeast can count on about two solid months of fishing for migrating stripers between Labor Day and New Year’s, there’s a “blink-and-you’ll-miss-it” feel that causes us to cast with a sense of urgency that wasn’t present back when the bass were migrating north.

To help make the most of this year’s fall striper migration, we’ve compiled this “Survival Guide” by surveying some of the most dedicated surfcasters in the Northeast and sharing some of our favorite tips for the final months of the striper season. – Jimmy Fee


Find the Bait…

Right alongside the migrating stripers, a great variety of baitfish are also heading to their wintering grounds in the fall. With many calories needed to fuel their long swims south, stripers aren’t picky about what they consume. I’ve seen fall bass blitzing on snapper blues, northern kingfish, hickory shad, bunker big and small, mullet, anchovies, lizardfish, sea herring, and mantis shrimp, yet there is a clear hierarchy of baitfish that pose the greatest benefit to striper-seeking surfcasters.

Of the 30 hardcore surfcasters we surveyed, here’s the breakdown of the baitfish they are most excited to see in the fall.

Bay Anchovies

“’Chovies! Everything of all shapes and sizes eats them. It’s so cool to see how they stain the water and spray like the gold coins from Scrooge McDuck.”
– Stephen Lobosco, New York

bay anchovies
Striped bass can swallow bay anchovies by the dozens.

Related Article: Striped Bass on Rain Bait


Menhaden and Mackerel

“Bunker and macks because stripers like them even more than I like pot roast.”
– East End Eddie Doherty, Massachusetts

A wall of schooling bunker (Photo by Tim Regan @southforksalt)

Related Article: The Bunker Handbook


Squid

“When the squid boats are dragging within site of the surf, the fishing’s usually pretty good.”
– Earl Evans, Van Staal Reels, Rhode Island

Squid go airborne while fleeing from hungry stripers (S16 Ep. 5 OTW’s Angling Adventures)

Related Article: Catching Calamari-Crazed Stripers


Mullet

Mullet. I get excited, because they don’t always show up. There are just a few spots I fish where they are a possibility, and if everything lines up right, it is almost guaranteed to be incredible fishing.”
– Jerry Audet, In Deep Outdoors, Massachusetts

Mullet (Photo by Tom Lynch – AngryFish.TV)

Article: The Northeast’s Mullet Run


Peanut Bunker

“Peanut Bunker. The absolute craziest blitzes I’ve seen have been fueled by peanuts.”
– Steve Gallant, Massachusetts

airborn peanut bunker
Peanut bunker flee from hungry stripers below. (Photo by Joey Manansala)

Related Article: The Peanut Bunker Boom


“This will sound crazy, but I don’t worry about bait too much in the fall. I search for the most productive migration highways and find areas that put me in the best position to intercept the bass on their way south.”
– Anthony Pizzella, Maine

Related Content

Fall Run Survival Guide: Essential Lures

Teasers for Fall Run Stripers

Have the Best Fall Run Ever

WATCH: Encore | Fall Run Finale – OTW Shorts

8 on “Baitfish of the Fall Run | Fall Run Survival Guide

  1. Scott b.

    Simply KILLER ,AWESOME,,, THE WHOLE SEACOAST,,,SURFCASTERS TOO,,,, AND STACKED UP DEEP ON LAST 2 OCTOBER WEEKS AT SOUTHWEST LEDGE ,, BETWEEN THE BLOCK AND MONTAUK POINT…

  2. Wi9lliam Wyrebek

    This is a very informative resource. I am 72 yrs old and do not get around as well or as long as I used to. I am staying with family in Hull, MA. Any suggestions for surf fishing areas that I could try out? I will not have much of an impact as my stamina lasts just about an hour. Any kind of fish would be great (except for eels, ugh!) Thanks in advance for any assistance.
    BillWyrebek

  3. William Wyrebek

    Your comment is awaiting moderation.

    This is a very informative resource. I am 72 yrs old and do not get around as well or as long as I used to. I am staying with family in Hull, MA. Any suggestions for surf fishing areas that I could try out? I will not have much of an impact as my stamina lasts just about an hour. Any kind of fish would be great (except for eels, ugh!) Thanks in advance for any assistance.
    BillWyrebek

  4. Kyle daley

    Very interesting comment’s but without a doubt if targeting larger bass adult bunker are what you’re looking for during the fall run. Tight lines all !!!

  5. Kyle daley

    Should add to what I said you will see a big explosion in the water when they hit the peanuts but with adult bunkers they take to the air so you’ll see them airborne that’s when you know great things could happen.

  6. Tracy Bagley

    I went off of the plum island shore Sunday and caught numerous very large blue fish . They were hitting on tinker mackerel and deep diving rapala’s .we were in 40 ft of water but they were also catching them from the beach. Awesome day!

  7. Simcha Fish heh

    I live in Far Rockaway any good spots to go for bass from shore

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *